Presentation + Paper
4 March 2019 Is there a safety-net effect with computer-aided detection (CAD)?
Ethan Du-Crow, Lucy Warren, Susan M. Astley, Johan Hulleman
Author Affiliations +
Computer-Aided Detection (CAD) systems are used to aid readers interpreting screening mammograms. An expert reader searches the image initially unaided, and then once again with the aid of CAD which prompts automatically detected suspicious regions. This could lead to a ‘safety-net’ effect, where the initial unaided search of the image is adversely affected by the fact that it is preliminary to an additional search with CAD, and may, therefore, be less thorough. To investigate the existence of such an effect, we created a visual search experiment for non-expert observers mirroring breast screening with CAD. Each observer searched 100 images for microcalcification clusters within synthetic images in both prompted and unprompted (no-CAD) conditions. Fifty-two participants were recruited for the study, 48 of whom had their eye movements tracked in real-time; four participants could not be accurately calibrated so only behavioural data was collected. In the CAD condition, before prompts were displayed, image coverage was significantly lower than coverage in the no-CAD condition (t(47)=5.48, p<0.001). Observer sensitivity was significantly greater for targets marked by CAD than the same targets in the no-CAD condition (t(51)=11.67, p<0.001). For targets not marked by CAD, there was no significant difference in observer sensitivity in the CAD condition compared to the same targets in the no-CAD condition (t(51)=0.88, p=0.382). These results suggest that the initial search may be influenced by the subsequent availability of CAD; if so, CAD efficacy studies should account for the effect when estimating benefit.
Conference Presentation
© (2019) COPYRIGHT Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers (SPIE). Downloading of the abstract is permitted for personal use only.
Ethan Du-Crow, Lucy Warren, Susan M. Astley, and Johan Hulleman "Is there a safety-net effect with computer-aided detection (CAD)?", Proc. SPIE 10952, Medical Imaging 2019: Image Perception, Observer Performance, and Technology Assessment, 109520J (4 March 2019); Logo
Cited by 1 scholarly publication.
Get copyright permission  Get copyright permission on Copyright Marketplace
Computer aided diagnosis and therapy

Target detection


Computer-aided diagnosis


CAD systems



Back to Top