An important aspect of research in optical coherence tomography (OCT) is the validation of new systems, novel techniques, and theoretical predictions using phantoms with optical properties that closely approximate those of tissue.1 Numerous such phantoms have been proposed;1, 2, 3 however, issues exist with each of these phantoms and no previously published phantom has become universally accepted within the OCT community. OCT phantoms generally comprise a bulk matrix, which provides a scaffold, and additives, which provide optical absorption and scattering. For many experiments, it is important to use a matrix that allows for the incorporation of the natural constituents of tissue, such as blood and fat, to closely approximate tissue optical properties.1
Room-temperature vulcanizing (RTV) silicone, epoxy resin, and polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) gels are commonly used matrix materials.1, 2, 3 However, these materials are not compatible with biological materials; therefore, inorganic scatterers must be used, typically white metal-oxide powders or microspheres. White metal-oxide powders, such as aluminum oxide and titanium dioxide , have the disadvantage that their refractive index is much higher than that of tissue, resulting in phantoms with overall optical properties very different to those of tissue. An alternative is the more expensive dry silica microspheres, which have low size variations and a refractive index closer to tissue. However, it is difficult to achieve homogenously scattering phantoms with these particles due to aggregation.2 For PVA gels, scattering is deliberately introduced into the matrix material by performing a series of freeze/thaw cycles.3 However, PVA gels are not biologically compatible. Phantoms based on biologically compatible gelatin and agarose hydrogels have been used as phantom materials.1 Scattering from the gelatin matrix has been reported, which is undesirable as it limits the degree to which scattering is controlled by additive concentration. Such gelatin and agarose phantoms typically have short lifetimes of less than one week, and do not maintain their rigidity at room temperature.1
In this work, we present novel, biocompatible phantoms based on a low-scattering matrix material that improves key attributes associated with commonly used phantom materials, including time-efficient fabrication, longer lifetime, rigidity at room temperature, and low scattering. We define biocompatible as a material that is suitable for the addition of biological materials and substances such as the constituents of tissue. The matrix material used is fibrin, which is employed as an adhesive in surgical procedures and wound closures.4, 5 Fibrin is a naturally occurring protein in humans that provides structural support for blood clots. It is formed from the protein fibrinogen by proteolysis induced by the enzyme thrombin. To demonstrate fibrin’s potential, we used it to fabricate phantoms with optical scattering coefficients similar to those of tissue by incorporating it with Intralipid™. The main advantages of Intralipid are its well-known optical properties6 and the similarity of its microparticles to lipid cell membranes and organelles that constitute the scattering sources in tissue.1 The result is a homogeneous, uniformly scattering phantom, with a scattering coefficient that can be controlled by the concentration of Intralipid. Single and bilayer phantoms were fabricated and imaged using OCT. This paper provides the first description of fibrin-based OCT phantoms, detailing both fabrication techniques and the resulting optical properties.
Fibrin phantoms were fabricated using a mixture of fibrinogen and thrombin, both extracted from bovine plasma (Sigma-Aldrich, Germany). A quantity of of thrombin powder was dissolved in of saline, to which of calcium chloride was added. reduces the clotting time and increases the elasticity of fibrin gels.4 Separately, of fibrinogen powder (65% to 85% protein) was dissolved in of saline and mixed with a suitable volume of standard 20% Intralipid, where 20% signifies the percentage weight per volume (w/v) of soy bean oil. A volume of 20% Intralipid contained of soybean oil, of egg lecithin, of glycerol, and water. The fibrinogen/Intralipid and thrombin/ solutions were mixed in a 3:2 volume ratio. The solution was set in a cylindrical mold of diameter and thickness . After clotting time, the fibrin phantom was placed in saline and stored in the refrigerator. This procedure resulted in a homogeneous distribution of optical scatterers, without observable aggregation. Bilayer phantoms were fabricated by pouring fibrin into the base of the mold in two steps. By controlling the volume of solution added to the mold, a thin layer (with 1% w/v Intralipid) was fabricated, followed by a thicker layer (with 13% w/v Intralipid) added later.
Scanning electron microscope (SEM) images of a single-layer fibrin phantom were obtained. To record the images, a -thick section of fibrin phantom was prepared by freeze drying in liquid nitrogen, and a platinum surface coating was applied. The magnification was and the accelerating voltage was . In addition, confocal fluorescence microscopy images of a similar phantom were obtained. The phantom was eosin stained for to introduce fluorescent optical contrast, then rinsed in water for and imaged at a magnification of .
To quantify the attenuation coefficient in fibrin phantoms, we used the technique described in Ref. 7. The sample reflectance measured from the OCT signal is proportional to the product of the confocal point-spread function (PSF) with the single-scattering model for light attenuation in tissue7:represents physical path length, and corresponds to the sample interface, is the position of the confocal gate, is the apparent Rayleigh length used to characterize the point-spread function (PSF), and represents the attenuation coefficient. The confocal PSF was measured experimentally by moving a reflector through the focus of the sample beam and recording the detector output. As and the confocal PSF were measured experimentally, Eq. 1 could be used to extract from measured OCT A-scans.
The attenuation coefficient of fibrin phantoms was measured using a time-domain OCT (TD-OCT) system. A broadband source ( , , axial resolution ) with an optical power of was employed. The theoretical lateral resolution was .
3-D datasets were recorded with . The reflectance was extracted from the OCT signal by calibration from a series of reflectance standards. To reduce the effect of speckle on the calculation of , regions of in the plane were averaged. A swept-source OCT system (Thorlabs, Newton, New Jersey) was used to image the bilayer fibrin phantom. A broadband source ( , , axial resolution ) with an optical power of was employed. The theoretical lateral resolution was .
Results and Discussion
A scanning electron microscope image of a fibrin phantom, without Intralipid, is shown in Fig. 1 . During the clotting process, the fibrin fibers aggregate and branch to form a 3-D matrix. This fibrous structure is shown in Fig. 1. The nanoscale of the structure results in a sufficiently low optical scattering cross section for the phantom to be optically transparent at wavelengths used for OCT. Figure 1 shows a confocal fluorescence microscope image of a fibrin phantom prepared with 19% w/v Intralipid. Fig. 1 shows the homogeneous nature of the fluorescence. The air-phantom interface is visible in the top-left. The dark, largely circular features present throughout the image and ranging in size from are believed to be lipid droplets, which appear dark due to the absence of eosin.
The measured values of for phantoms with varying concentrations of Intralipid are presented in Fig. 2 . For each concentration, measurements were recorded at intervals of and averaged. The error bars represent one standard deviation (SD), calculated from five data points. A monotonic increase in scattering was measured for increasing Intralipid concentration. The values of presented in Fig. 2 are within the range of previously measured values for both tissue8 and Intralipid.6 In the inset of Fig. 2, the reflectance is plotted as a function of . The slope (red line) is proportional to . The gradual increase in reflectance over the first is attributed to diffusion of index-matching glycerol into the phantom near the boundary. The measured values of were stable for a period of approximately two weeks. After this, leaching of the Intralipid resulted in a reduction in . However, the fibrin matrix remained intact for more than one month.
An OCT B-scan of a bilayer fibrin phantom is presented in Fig. 3 . Higher scattering in the thicker layer is visible. The values of measured using the TD-OCT system in the thin and thick layers were , SD , and , SD , respectively. Comparing these values with Fig. 2, in the thin layer (Intralipid concentration 1%) is higher than expected, while in the thick layer (Intralipid concentration 13%) is lower than expected. We speculate that these differences are due to leaching of Intralipid from the thick layer to the thin layer during fabrication. This leaching could potentially be reduced by fabricating the phantoms at lower temperature. We subsequently observed a constant from both layers over a two-week period. We verified the integrity of the phantom over time by visual inspection. The homogeneity of each layer is visible in Fig. 3. The small inhomogeneities visible in the first layer are caused by small variations in Intralipid concentration resulting from imperfect mixing. The interface between layers is located at a depth in optical path length of approximately .
The fibrin phantoms presented in this work are suitable for use in a wide range of experiments in OCT. The fabrication time for the phantom was approximately . In comparison, bilayer silicone phantoms fabricated in our laboratory require up to fabrication time.9 The demonstrated homogeneity of fibrin phantoms will be important, for example, in studies of speckle in OCT, and measurement and use of the OCT scattering coefficient.7, 10 Investigations of the scattering properties of tissue constituents could be performed, and is the subject of ongoing work. Fibrin phantoms have the further advantage that they are pliable and exhibit a viscoelastic response that is in the range of biological tissues. It has been reported that the elastic modulus of fibrin can be changed by varying the thrombin concentration.5 Thus, fibrin phantoms could be useful in OCT elastography studies.9, 11 It has further been reported that the viscosity of fibrin can be varied by increasing the fibrinogen concentration,5 potentially mimicking the viscous properties of tissue. The ability to match a phantom’s mechanical properties to those of tissue is important for interstitial OCT measurements and/or procedures in solid tissues.12 Tumor-mimicking features can readily be incorporated into the fibrin matrix for such experiments.
Novel fibrin-based tissue-mimicking phantoms for use in OCT are presented. Fibrin phantoms overcome problems that exist in other biocompatible phantoms, such as scattering from the matrix, loss of rigidity at room temperature, and a short lifetime, and have a shorter fabrication time than commonly used phantoms. The fibrin matrix is optically transparent and compatible with both organic and inorganic optical scatterers. We demonstrate that fibrin phantoms incorporating Intralipid are homogeneous, provide controllable optical attenuation, and can readily be fabricated into two layers with distinct optical properties. These phantoms are well suited to a range of OCT experiments, in particular, those requiring homogeneous scattering, the addition of biological scatterers, and potentially those requiring viscoelastic properties matched to those of tissue. Fibrin phantoms have the potential to be adopted in a wide range of OCT applications.
The authors acknowledge the facilities, and scientific and technical assistance (in particular Peter Duncan) of the Australian Microscopy and Microanalysis Research Facility at the Centre for Microscopy, Characterisation and Analysis, The University of Western Australia, a facility funded by The University, State, and Commonwealth Governments.
C. E. Bisaillon, G. Lamouche, R. Maciejko, M. Dufour, and J. P. Monchalin, “Deformable and durable phantoms with controlled density of scatterers,” Phys. Med. Biol.0031-9155 53, 237–247 (2008).10.1088/0031-9155/53/13/N01Google Scholar
C. U. Devi, R. M. Vasu, and A. K. Sood, “Design, fabrication, and characterization of a tissue-equivalent phantom for optical elastography,” J. Biomed. Opt.1083-3668 10(4), 1–10 (2005).10.1117/1.2003833Google Scholar
D. S. Feldman, and D. H. Sierra, “Tissue adhesives in wound healing,” Chap. 40 in Encyclopedic Handbook of Biomaterials and Bioengineering, Part A: Materials, D. L. Wise, D. J. Trantolo, D. E. Altobelli, M. J. Yaszemski, J. D. Gresser, and E. R. Schwartz, Eds., pp. 1347–1384, Marcel Dekker, New York (1995).Google Scholar
H. Kaetsu, T. Uchida, and N. Shinya, “Increased effectiveness of fibrin sealant with a higher fibrin concentration,” Int. J. Adhes. Adhes.0143-7496 20, 27–31 (2000).10.1016/S0143-7496(99)00011-1Google Scholar
H. J. van Staveren, C. J. M. Moes, J. van Marle, S. A. Prahl, and M. J. C. van Gemert, “Light scattering in intralipid-10% in the wavelength range of ,” Appl. Opt.0003-6935 30(31), 4507–4514 (1991).10.1364/AO.30.004507Google Scholar
D. J. Faber, F. J. Van der Meer, and M. C. G. Aalders, “Quantitative measurements of attenuation coefficients of weakly scattering media using optical coherence tomography,” Opt. Express1094-4087 12(19), 4353–4365 (2004).10.1364/OPEX.12.004353Google Scholar
V. Tuchin, Tissue Optics: Light Scattering Methods and Instruments for Medical Diagnosis, SPIE Press, Bellingham, WA (2007).Google Scholar
B. F. Kennedy, T. R. Hillman, R. A. McLaughlin, B. C. Quirk, and D. D. Sampson, “In vivo dynamic optical coherence elastography using a ring actuator,” Opt. Express1094-4087 17(24), 21762–21772 (2009).10.1364/OE.17.021762Google Scholar
R. A. McLaughlin, L. Scolaro, P. Robbins, C. Saunders, S. L. Jacques, and D. D. Sampson, “Mapping tissue optical attenuation to identify cancer using optical coherence tomography,” in Proc. MICCAI, Lect. Notes Comput. Sci.0302-9743 5762, 657–664 (2009).10.1007/978-3-642-04271-3_80Google Scholar