The survivors of almost 500,000 burn injuries that receive medical treatment each year in the U.S. face immense social and economic costs during their recovery and reintegration period.1,2 Characterization of burn injuries during the early postinjury assessment period is a critical decision point in determining the management course, healing process, and ultimate outcome, since the treatment of a given burn differs considerably depending upon the results of the initial assessment. Burns are usually classified according to the depth of the damaged skin in three clinically useful categories: first-, second-, and third-degree.2 In a full-thickness or third-degree burn, the entire depth of the skin, through the stratum corneum, epidermis, and dermis layers, is destroyed. In a partial-thickness (second-degree) burn, the extent of the damage is contained within the dermis layer. Finally, first-degree or superficial burns only involve the epidermis layer of the skin and usually heal without any scars or need for medical care. The clinical course of treatment is substantially different for burns of greater severity. Third-degree injuries cannot heal without surgical and skin grafting procedures, whereas for second-degree wounds, the recovery progress consists of careful monitoring and infection prevention over a 2- to 3-week period after the burn.2,3 During this period, a subgroup of the second-degree burns will spontaneously heal, while others will develop to a full-thickness state and will require surgical intervention.2 The complex nature of partial-thickness burns is due to the extent of irreversible thermal damage to the microvasculature and the new epithelium generation sites. If an insufficient number of microvascular and epithelium generation structures survive after the injuries, the remaining viable parts of the dermis layer will slowly desiccate and eventually reach the third-degree injury level.2,4 Therefore, in order to investigate the utility of a diagnosis technique for differentiating second-degree burns from third-degree ones, in vivo animal models should be employed, as opposed to ex vivo studies, due to the complex dynamics of wound healing after thermal injury.
State of the Art in Assessment of Burn Injuries
The accuracy rate of current clinical assessment technique to differentiate between burn grades, based mainly on visual inspection by experienced surgeons, is only about 65% to 70%.2,5 Highly accurate differentiation and delineation of burn wounds can potentially alter management, reduce length of hospital stay, and improve overall recovery for the burn patient. For instance, a noninvasive clinical diagnostic modality that could guide the treatment plan by predicting the healing outcome of second-degree burns and guide surgical delineation to minimize the scar formation would be of significant value. This idea has motivated the development of a wide variety of invasive and noninvasive diagnostic tools,2 which are usually benchmarked against histology as the gold standard. These techniques include, for example, indocyanine green dye fluorescence imaging,3,6 nuclear magnetic resonance imaging,7 ultrasonography,8 contact dielectric measurement at radio frequencies,9 multispectral optical reflection imaging,5 laser Doppler imaging,10 polarization-sensitive optical coherence tomography,11 and near-infrared spectroscopy.12,13 Although some of these techniques have shown promising results, they still have not been able to achieve sufficient specificity and sensitivity, as compared with histological assessment of wound biopsies. Moreover, significant problems have limited the implementation of such modalities in clinical environments, including cost effectiveness and compatibility to routine patient care.2
Terahertz Modality for Characterization of Burn Wounds
The terahertz part of the electromagnetic spectrum, known as the so-called “THz gap,” is usually defined by the frequencies between 100 GHz and 10 THz (wavelengths from 3 mm to 30 μm).14 The high absorption of terahertz radiation by both bound and free water molecules provides a sensitive signal contrast for imaging applications.15 Difference in the water content of the tissue has been recently proposed as the main basis for many biomedical and biological applications of terahertz radiation.1617.–18 Pickwell et al. furthermore showed that a double Debye dielectric relaxation model can be used to describe the terahertz response of healthy human skin,19,20 which is very similar to the model often used for polar liquids.21 Pulsed-terahertz emissions have also been used to image and delineate basal cell carcinoma2223.–24 and human breast cancer tumor margins,25,26 based on the differences in the water content of the cancerous tumor versus healthy tissue.27
Terahertz reflectometry and imaging has recently been proposed for the diagnosis of burn injuries ex vivo2829.–30 and in vivo.3132.–33 We have previously shown that the double Debye model, proposed by Pickwell et al.,19 can be extended to explain the higher terahertz reflectivity of moderate burn samples immediately postinjury.30 In accordance with the general burn literature,2 an increase in the water content of the burned tissue, due to formation of interstitial edema, has been experimentally observed using THz spectroscopy.3031.32.–33 Furthermore, we proposed that the sensitivity of THz waves to the postburn reduction in the number and size of discrete normal skin structures, such as microvasculature, sweat glands, and hair follicles can be used as a source of signal contrast in THz burn imaging.30,33
In this paper, we formulate a hypothesis for a burn diagnosis criterion based on in vivo terahertz reflection spectroscopy results obtained from second- and third-degree burns over a 72-hour period after injury. In order to do so, we first introduce an image processing approach to objectively quantify the density of skin structures (DOS) in histological sections of tissue samples. We then show that a strong statistical correlation exists between the THz observations and the DOS metric.
Materials and Methods
The experimental animal model and burn protocol used in this study was approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee at the University of Washington. Male Sprague–Dawley rats (), weighing between 300 and 400 g, were divided into two groups. After the animal was anesthetized with isoflurane (4% for induction, 2% for maintenance, with flow rate of ), its back was shaved and epilated with hair remover lotion (Nair, Church & Dwight Co, Princeton, New Jersey). Two posterior sites corresponding approximately to the 12th thoracic vertebra were marked 3 cm laterally from the midline on both sides of the rats, one to create a burn and the other as the control tissue. Each group of rats received either a second-degree burn (), 100°C for 3 s, or third-degree burn (), 100°C for 30 s, while being maintained under analgesics for the duration of the experiments. A 313 g brass rod, with a 1 cm diameter cylindrical protrusion, was heated in a water bath maintained at 100°C. The cylindrical protrusion was then held against the marked site for the specified time using only the weight of the rod. Terahertz time-domain spectroscopy (THz-TDS) was used to measure the reflectivity of both control and burned tissue at a near normal incidence angle () immediately and at 72 h postburn. After the conclusion of the terahertz experiments on the third day, and after euthanasia by an overdose of pentobarbital (), biopsy samples were collected using a 3 mm punch. Hematoxylin and Eosin (H&E)-stained histology of all samples confirmed the consistent formation of second- and the third-degree burns using this protocol.
The THz-TDS setup used in this study was custom-made and consisted of an 800 nm 50 fs Ti:Saphire laser (Micra, Coherent Inc., Santa Clara, California), which by impinging upon a biased photoconductive antenna (Zomega Terahertz Corporation, East Greenbush, New York), built with 100 μm gap on low-temperature GaAs, generated the terahertz waves. Terahertz radiation was first collimated and then focused, using a pair of off-axis parabolic gold mirrors, on the samples placed on a fused-silica imaging window. Upon reflection from the burned and normal skin samples, the terahertz waves were detected via the electro-optic sampling method in a 1 mm thick ZnTe crystal. The entire THz-TDS system was enclosed in a box and purged with dry to eliminate the absorption features of ambient humidity from the experimental results.
Self-Calibration and Signal Processing
Before employing the fast Fourier transform (FFT) to investigate the spectral dependence of normal and burned skin samples, a split cosine taper was multiplied by the first and the last 20 to 25 points of the time series, and additional zeros were padded to both ends. The FFT amplitudes of the samples were normalized by the FFT of the differential reference to eliminate the effect of the intrinsic system response function. Moreover, to account for a typical terahertz signal amplitude drift in between measurements, the signal peak from the first interface of the slab, between air and fused silica, was used to self-calibrate each measurement with that of the references.30
Results and Discussion
Figure 1 shows microscope images of H&E-stained biopsy samples for several groups of second- and third-degree burns created with this protocol. Biopsy samples were blindly studied by histopathologists, confirming the existence of second- and third-degree burns, as appropriate, in every sample generated by this protocol. Nonetheless, these images show that even when the same physical protocol is used to create burns, a wide range of damage can result. This variation is mostly due to the random fluctuation of the number and size of normal skin constituents such as hair follicles, sweat glands, capillaries, etc. Most notably, we have observed three groups of skin burns, as represented in the columns of Fig. 1, based on the skin structures present after generation of second- and third-degree injuries. In the first column, a deeply coagulated layer of the burned tissue can be seen with few superficial cracks, while in the second column, a number of hair follicles and sweat ducts was identified in the burned regions of the dermis. The tissue samples in the third group exhibit a large density of various discrete skin structures.
THz-TDS measurements of burned and healthy (control) tissue were obtained using a self-calibrating technique through a fused-silica imaging window. The reflection measurements were obtained immediately and at 72 h postburn at an angle of incidence close to normal (). The 72-hour juncture was chosen based on the well-established peak of the standard inflammatory response of the tissue to thermal damage by the formation of interstitial edema.2,9,34 Due to the inhomogeneity of skin tissue, and especially because the size of normal skin structures are comparable to the terahertz wavelength, for each skin sample the average reflectivity over several (3 to 5) spatially disjoint terahertz realizations was obtained. Moreover, the spot size of the beam was approximately 2 mm in diameter at the focal point. Figure 2(a) and 2(b) shows the normalized excess terahertz reflectivity of burns, induced with either 100°C for 3 s or 100°C for 30 s protocol, immediately and at 72 h postinjury. The error bars show the full range of the data obtained over different rats used in the study. The progression of the burn injuries can be seen by the comparison between the acute and the 72-hour characterization of the wounds. It is evident that the large degree of variability between samples renders the simple use of the percentage change in the THz reflectivity relative to healthy (control) tissue too ineffectual for the discrimination of burn severity.
This observation is in part because burn wounds are not static in their physiological nature.2,9,35 For example, as explained earlier, some of the second-degree injuries can reach a full-thickness depth (third degree) within a few days, due to the extent of thermal damage to the microvasculature and epithelium generation sites. This dynamic nature of the wound further complicates burn triage at the time of patient presentation.
Density of Skin Structures
Histopathological study of wound biopsies remains the gold standard of the burn depth assessment despite its invasive and time-consuming nature. Even though there still does not exist any universally accepted benchmark for inference of burn depth from histological sections,36 the accuracy of all other technological aids are usually measured against this method. The complexity of the dynamic molecular and cellular level changes, which skin constituents experience postburn, gives rise to most of the discrepancies in this field. For instance, while some studies indicate that the patency of microvasculature at the burn sites is the most critical factor in recovery,36 other methods emphasize cellular and epithelial intactness as the main predictor for wound healing.2 The presence of discrete skin structures, which are also known to be determinants of the healing likelihood of the burned skin,11–12,34,36 can potentially give rise to scattering of electromagnetic waves as they propagate through skin layers. In this section, we introduce a simple image processing method to objectively quantify the DOS in an attempt to relate our histopathological findings to the THz observations.
Figure 3(a) shows a flowchart diagram of the steps involved in the image processing of the histology sections to count each pixel associated with the discrete structures in the burned and normal skin samples. The algorithm first identifies the skin edge, and subsequently defines a search area approximately 400 μm deep in the tissue. It then recognizes tissue structures such as microvascular capillaries, hair follicles, sweat glands, and their skin duct based on the ratio of the red and blue components of the acquired image in comparison to the two detection thresholds, and . To determine these threshold values, we used two groups of the histological sections as learning subsets: (1) deeply coagulated tissue with only minor superficial skin cracks (usually of lighter colors) and (2) burned tissue including only dark-colored hair follicles and shafts. Each group included two skin biopsy samples and four cross section images per biopsy. We varied the values of and within the search domain for the learning subsets until all pixels associated with white skin cracks or dark hair structures were correctly identified by the algorithm. The determined threshold values were then used for all remaining histological images that presented a more complex collection of skin structures. Finally, the program calculates the total areal density of such structures within the search area. This density value is the largest ( to 30%) for healthy skin, and the more severely the tissue is damaged, the smaller the DOS will be. Figure 3(b) and 3(c) shows typical outcomes of the image processing routine for a full-thickness and partial-thickness burn sample, respectively.
Figure 4 maps out our experimental results in the form of a scatter plot, where the -axis shows the average reflectivity of skin samples between 0.2 and 1 THz, while the -axis shows the spectral slope or rate of change in reflectivity with respect to frequency at 72 h postinjury. The color code is determined by averaging the DOS metric from the image processing analysis of up to four histological sections of each tissue biopsy. Individual symbol types correspond to individual rats. The dotted lines, which are vertically offset for clarity, are drawn here as a visual aid. It can be seen that while all normal samples are aggregated in the lower left quadrant of the figure, the burned tissue data are spread out according to the degree of deviation of the THz reflectivity from their respective normal controls. In this plot, the excess reflectivity along the -axis is generally attributed to the formation of interstitial edema at the burned sites.3031.32.–33 However, the change in the spectral slope of the THz reflectivity (THz color of the burns), which is shown in the -axis, is not well understood. One possible explanation suggests that a potential change in the dispersive properties of normal skin as a result of the thermal insult as well as absorption by the water content of the tissue may be responsible for this observation. It may also be consistent with a reduction in electromagnetic scattering of terahertz waves due to a decrease in the density of discrete scatterers, i.e., the DOS value, as we observe here. Specifically, in all normal tissue samples, where the DOS is the largest, the normalized THz reflectivity showed a steep roll-off with higher frequencies, resulting in negative slope values along the -axis for the blue symbols in Fig. 4. However, the burned samples demonstrated near-zero or positive spectral slopes, suggesting reduced scattering levels as the DOS value decreases.
From this map, we infer that some of the second-degree injuries were severe enough to reach DOS values comparable to third-degree burns within 72 hours. For example in Fig. 4, the burn sample marked with was created with a second-degree protocol, but in both THz spectroscopy response and DOS, it has reached values corresponding to a full-thickness burn. We can also confirm from histological sections that other samples showed signs of healing within the same period. For instance, the second-degree burn with DOS estimated at 15%, placed very closely to its normal (control) tissue on the scatter plot, illustrates this effect. Of the nine rats in our survival studies, we found only one outlier to this general trend (a nominally second-degree burn with DOS value of 7.7%).
These results suggest that while discrimination of burn severity cannot be ascertained solely based on the absolute value of the terahertz reflectivity, a combined measure of reflectivity () and spectral slope () can differentiate among them based on the DOS metric. We define this combined measure, , with a linear combination of and , as given in Eq. (1),Fig. 4 perpendicular to the dashed lines. It should also be noted that limiting the range of variables and does not constrain the possible linear combinations of THz reflectivity and spectral slope, when and are varied simultaneously and therefore their ratio can be quite large. Figure 5 summarizes our hypothesis for a new burn diagnosis criterion using this combined measure, , when . Specifically, we hypothesize that the anticorrelation relation between DOS and , as shown in Fig. 5, can be used to infer the severity of burn injuries, and therefore their likelihood for spontaneous healing, when THz radiation is used to interrogate the intactness of skin structures.
Large scale experimental studies, complete with statistical models, are necessary before the usefulness of the -value criterion in predicting the healing outcome of partial-thickness burns can be verified. In order to develop such statistical models, the progress of different burn grades should be monitored over a 2- to 3-week period to determine which values of DOS and correspond to the samples that naturally heal, while others require surgical intervention.
We have presented experimental results from in vivo THz-TDS of second- and third-degree burns in a survival study over the 72-hour period postinjury. We showed examples of the wide range of histopathological manifestation of burned tissue that must be characterized during triage for successful treatment of burns. We then introduced an image processing approach to objectively quantify the severity of these injuries based on the DOS metric. We showed that the terahertz response of different burn grades is not only consistent with the presumed overall water content in the tissue, but also correlates with the density of discrete scattering structures within the skin layers. These observations suggest, in turn, a new diagnosis criterion for clinical discrimination of burn injuries based on the THz response of the tissue.
M. Hassan Arbab is grateful to Dr. Eric Thorsos for reviewing the manuscript and for helpful suggestions. This work was partially supported by the Washington Research Foundation.
J. M. Stillet al., “Diagnosis of burn depth using laser-induced indocyanine green fluorescence: a preliminary clinical trial,” Burns 27(4), 364–371 (2001).BURND80305-4179http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0305-4179(00)00140-6Google Scholar
M. A. Afromowitzet al., “Multispectral imaging of burn wounds: a new clinical instrument for evaluating burn depth,” IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng. 35(10), 842–850 (1988).IEBEAX0018-9294http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/10.7291Google Scholar
H. A. Greenet al., “Burn depth estimation using indocyanine green fluorescence,” Arch. Dermatol. 128(1), 43–49 (1992).ARDEAC0003-987Xhttp://dx.doi.org/10.1001/archderm.1992.01680110053005Google Scholar
M. J. Korudaet al., “Assessing burn wound depth using in vitro nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR),” J. Surg. Res. 40(5), 475–481 (1986).JSGRA20022-4804http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0022-4804(86)90218-0Google Scholar
S. Iranihaet al., “Determination of burn depth with noncontact ultrasonography,” J. Burn Care Res. 21(4), 333–338 (2000).1559-047Xhttp://dx.doi.org/10.1097/00004630-200021040-00008Google Scholar
A. Pappet al., “Dielectric measurement in experimental burns: a new tool for burn depth determination?,” Plast. Reconstr. Surg. 117(3), 889–898 (2006).PRSUAS0032-1052http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/01.prs.0000197213.12989.03Google Scholar
A. D. Jaskilleet al., “Critical review of burn depth assessment techniques: part II. Review of laser Doppler technology,” J. Burn Care Res. 31(1), 151–157 (2010).1559-047Xhttp://dx.doi.org/10.1097/BCR.0b013e3181c7ed60Google Scholar
S. M. Srinivaset al., “Determination of burn depth by polarization-sensitive optical coherence tomography,” J. Biomed. Opt. 9(1), 207–212 (2004).JBOPFO1083-3668http://dx.doi.org/10.1117/1.1629680Google Scholar
K. M. Crosset al., “Clinical utilization of near-infrared spectroscopy devices for burn depth assessment,” Wound Repair Regen. 15(3), 332–340 (2007).http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1524-475X.2007.00235.xGoogle Scholar
J. Federici, “Review of moisture and liquid detection and mapping using terahertz imaging,” J. Infrared Milli. Terahertz. Waves 33(2), 97–126 (2012).1866-6892http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10762-011-9865-7Google Scholar
J. T. KindtC. A. Schmuttenmaer, “Far-infrared dielectric properties of polar liquids probed by femtosecond terahertz pulse spectroscopy,” J. Phys. Chem. 100(24), 10373–10379 (1996).JPCHAX0022-3654http://dx.doi.org/10.1021/jp960141gGoogle Scholar
R. M. Woodwardet al., “Terahertz pulse imaging of ex vivo basal cell carcinoma,” J. Investig. Dermatol. 120(1), 72–78 (2003).JIDEAE0022-202Xhttp://dx.doi.org/10.1046/j.1523-1747.2003.12013.xGoogle Scholar
V. P. Wallaceet al., “Terahertz pulsed imaging of basal cell carcinoma ex vivo and in vivo,” Br. J. Dermatol. 151(2), 424–432 (2004).BJDEAZ0007-0963http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/bjd.2004.151.issue-2Google Scholar
R. M. Woodwardet al., “Terahertz pulse imaging in reflection geometry of human skin cancer and skin tissue,” Phys. Med. Biol. 47(21), 3853–3863 (2002).PHMBA70031-9155http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0031-9155/47/21/325Google Scholar
P. C. Ashworthet al., “Terahertz pulsed spectroscopy of freshly excised human breast cancer,” Opt. Express 17(15), 12444–12454 (2009).OPEXFF1094-4087http://dx.doi.org/10.1364/OE.17.012444Google Scholar
P. Tewariet al., “Advances in biomedical imaging using THz technology with applications to burn-wound assessment,” Proc. SPIE 8261, 82610T (2012).PSISDG0277-786Xhttp://dx.doi.org/10.1117/12.915987Google Scholar
T. W. PankeC. G. McLeold, Pathology of Thermal Injury: a Practical Approach, Grune & Stratton, Orlando, FL (1985).Google Scholar
D. J. McGillet al., “Assessment of burn depth: a prospective, blinded comparison of laser Doppler imaging and videomicroscopy,” Burns 33(7), 833–842 (2007).BURND80305-4179http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.burns.2006.10.404Google Scholar