Neuronal activity occurs on a millisecond time scale across cell circuits distributed over the entire nervous system. Capturing these spatiotemporal patterns at adequate sampling rates to uncover the underlying principles of neuronal information processing is a grand technical challenge for systems neuroscience. Recently, it became possible in transparent reporter zebrafish larvae expressing genetically encoded fluorescent calcium indicators (GECIs)1,2 to detect calcium transients noninvasively in the whole nervous system. In this vertebrate model organism, imaging can thus deliver information about a close correlate of neuronal activation, calcium fluxes, at much higher spatial resolution than is achievable with electrophysiological point recordings. To exceed the speed of confocal or multiphoton laser scanning methods,3 light sheet microscopy methods have recently been developed4–6 that image an entire plane through the object of interest at once, such that about neurons in an entire zebrafish larval brain can be scanned at a frequency of about 1 Hz.4 Volumetric acquisition can be accelerated even further by light field imaging, an elegant method that avoids having to scan the object but instead reconstructs it volumetrically from multiple views acquired simultaneously from many different angles. This imaging method has recently been adapted for microscopy by using arrays of microlenses projecting to subregions of sufficiently sensitive and large image sensors.7,8 Light field microscopy (also known as plenoptic microscopy) could thus, in principle, capture the majority of fluorescent neurons in the brain of a reporter zebrafish in a single acquisition without the need for interpolation to correct for time delays. Neuroimaging of reporter zebrafish would benefit directly from such a gain in imaging speed. For instance, state-of-the-art fast light sheet microscopy, operating at about one volume per second, still misses a substantial fraction of calcium fluctuations detected by sensors such as GCaMP5G (rise times of and decay rates of 1,4). For faster fluorescent sensors, such as genetically encoded voltage sensors,9 even higher frame rates10 would be required for adequate sampling. Furthermore, fast volumetric imaging could simultaneously extract information from fluorescent molecular sensors together with “biomechanical” data from freely moving zebrafish larvae exhibiting unrestrained behavior; this may complement virtual environment approaches that investigate neural activity during fictive behavior in immobilized zebrafish larvae.11 Lately, technical advances have been made in acquisition and reconstruction of light field microscopy data12–14 and three light field microscopes have been custom-built in different laboratories specifically to image neuronal activity in immobilized Caenorhabditis elegans worms and zebrafish larvae.8,14,15 Despite the generous provision of open access documentation on light field microscopy hardware and open source software,16,17 an “off-the shelf” light field camera system would certainly help to disseminate this comparably straightforward and compact imaging technology for widespread biological use. In this work, we thus investigated the performance of commercially available multifocus plenoptic cameras18 (Raytrix GmbH) for fluorescence neuroimaging of zebrafish larvae.
Results and Discussion
For initial testing of the commercial light field camera for microscopy, we imaged the distribution of melanin containing pigments in the head region of wild-type zebrafish larvae (6 days post fertilization) using a custom-assembled microscopy setup [Fig. 1(a)]. The larvae were embedded in 0.8% low-melting agarose and imaged under white light illumination ( objective from Nikon, 0.25 NA, FOV of , plenoptic camera; all animal experiments were conducted in accordance with the guidelines approved by the government of Upper Bavaria). As can be seen in Fig. 1, the head melanophores of the larva and the eyes offered high contrast [Fig. 1(b)] and their localization along the dorsoventral axis was correctly captured by the depth map calculated from the light field images exploiting information from microlenses with different focal lengths [Fig. 1(c)]. We subsequently tested the performance of the plenoptic camera for fluorescence microscopy by imaging green fluorescent beads of in diameter (FluoSpheres carboxylate, Life Technologies, Carlsbad, California) embedded in an agar phantom. The sample excitation and fluorescence detection was achieved via a 488-nm OBIS laser (Coherent), a dichroic mirror (510 nm, Chroma Technology Corp.), a objective (UMPlanFl N , 0.5 NA, FOV ) a emission filter (Chroma), and a plenoptic camera. Figure 1(d) shows the projection of single microspheres onto the image sensor, obtained via the microlens array consisting of microlenses with different focal lengths assembled in a hexagonal configuration.18 The corresponding volumetric reconstruction is shown in Fig. 1(d’) yielding a lateral resolution of and an axial resolution of (estimated by the averaged point spread function without additional postprocessing).
We were next interested to assess whether the light field microscopy setup could detect dynamic changes of neuronal activity in transgenic reporter zebrafish larvae with neuronal expression of a calcium indicator (HuC:GCaMP5g, identical optical setup as described above). To this end, we restrained zebrafish larvae in 0.8% low-melting agarose not covering the nose. We stimulated the larvae with the odorant cadaverine (Cad, solution), a diamine generated by decarboxylation of the amino acid lysine during decomposition of flesh, which is known to evoke olfactory-related neural activity and avoidance responses in zebrafish larvae.19,20 Figure 2 shows three image planes through the volumetrically reconstructed light field dataset [Fig. 2(a)], as well as a top-down maximum intensity projection [Fig. 2(b)] showing robust fluorescent signal. Regions of interest (ROIs) could be automatically selected based on thresholding voxel signal changes in response to cadaverine and clustered with respect to the correlation (correlation coefficient larger than 0.8) of their respective baseline-corrected time courses [color coded in Fig. 2(b’)]. Clusters of activity could be found in the olfactory bulb (OB) and habenula (Hb), the latter considered to be involved in relaying odor-evoked behavioral responses,19,20 as well as in some neurons of the optic tectum (OT) [Figs. 2(b)–2(c)]. Whereas calcium signal amplitudes increased in the OB after cadaverine delivery [the delivery period is labeled “cad” on the gray area in Fig. 2(b)] during the observed time window, they partially decreased after peaking a few seconds after delivery of cadaverine (white broken lines in all traces); signal trajectories in the OT showed the first response peak occurring ∽1 s earlier than in the OB followed by multiple weaker calcium waves.
Next, we explored whether we could simultaneously capture neuronal activity while recording behavioral responses to the aversive odorant using the light field microscopy setup. To this aim, we embedded HuC:GCaMP5g larvae in agarose such that the tail was free to move and chose a objective to obtain a field of view covering the entire larva. After cadaverine delivery, evoked neuronal calcium fluxes were recorded while concurrent tail movements were detected that are indicative of avoidance responses21 [Fig. 2(d)]. Cluster analysis on automatically detected ROIs on this dataset interestingly showed activation in areas of the hindbrain that were in synchrony with the tail movements [gray bars underneath the signal time courses in Fig. 2(d)].
In summary, using a commercially available plenoptic camera (Raytrix GmbH) mounted on a custom-built microscope, we were able to volumetrically resolve calcium-dependent fluorescent signal changes elicited by the aversive odorant cadaverine in the brains of behaving zebrafish larvae. The capability of light field microscopy to acquire an entire volume in a single shot enabled us to detect diverse temporal response profiles from neuronal structures at different depths throughout the larval brain that motivate future detailed investigations. The current turn-key plenoptic camera could be successfully used to extract meaningful volumetric information about calcium signaling in distinct brain regions of reporter fish. However, both the spatial and temporal resolutions of the imaging system could be strongly improved by combining custom-designed multilens arrays and optimized reconstruction algorithms with scientific sCMOS image sensors that should provide an about four times higher sensitivity. These hardware improvements could be effectively complemented by the use of reporter fish expressing GECIs localized to the cell nucleus (as opposed to the entire cell), thereby aiding volumetric extraction of cellular calcium transients from the nonisotropic voxels obtained from current light field microscopy setups. As light field imaging is an elegant solution for fast molecular bioimaging applications, it is to be hoped that plenoptic cameras could be further optimized for fast fluorescence microscopy and be made more widely available to the biomedical research community.
Shared authorships are listed in alphabetical order: A.L., P.S., A.E., C.C.-P., and G.G.W. conducted the experiments; M.C., P.S., A.L., A.E., and G.G.W. analyzed the data; and A.L., P.S., and G.G.W. wrote the manuscript. We thank Raytrix GmbH (Kiel, Germany) for their assistance with the light field camera during our experiments, Dr. Michael Orger (Champalimaud Centre for the Unknown, Lisbon, Portugal) and Dr. Hernan Lopez-Schier (SBO, Helmholtz Zentrum Muenchen, Germany) for sharing the zebrafish transgenic line HuC:GCaMP5g. G.G.W. and C.C.-P. acknowledge the support from the Helmholtz Alliance ICEMED. A.L. acknowledges the support from the Postodoctoral Fellowship Program (PFP) of the Helmholtz Zentrum München. G.G.W. and A.L. acknowledge the support from the European Research Council under grant agreement ERC-2012-StG- 311552.
Carlos Cruz Pérez received his Diploma in Telecommunication Engineering from Technical University of Madrid in 2013. He then joined the Institutes of Biological and Medical Imaging (IBMI) and Developmental Genetics (IDG) at Helmholtz Zentrum München to work on optical systems for neuroimaging.
Antonella Lauri received her MS degree in medical biotechnology from the University of Naples “Federico II,” Italy, in 2008. In 2013, she obtained her PhD (and Doctor of Science) from Heidelberg University and EMBL (European Molecular Biology Laboratory, Germany), applying different molecular and imaging methods to solve evolutionary and developmental questions. In 2013, she joined the Institutes of Biological and Medical Imaging and Developmental Genetics at Helmholtz Zentrum Muenchen, where she focuses on fish neuroimaging.
Panagiotis Symvoulidis received his Diploma in electrical and computer engineering from Technical University of Athens (NTUA), where he focused his studies on signal processing and electronics for biomedical engineering application. Subsequently, he moved to the Technische Universitaet Muenchen, where he worked toward his PhD under the supervision of Prof. V. Ntziachristos on the systems and algorithms for fluorescence and multispectral tissue imaging in the diffusive regime. Recently, he joined Prof. Westmeyer’s laboratory at Helmholtz Zentrum Muenchen, developing equipment and methods for neuroimaging studies.
Michele Cappetta has studied at the “University of the studies of Trieste” (Italy) where he obtained a Bachelor in physics in 2006 and his MS degree in astrophysics in 2008. In 2013 he concluded his PhD in physics at the Ludwig Maximilian University Munich conducting a research project on extrasolar planets at the Max-Planck-Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics in Munich. He became a member of IBMI and IDG the Helmholtz Zentrum Muenchen in 2014.
Gil Gregor Westmeyer completed his dissertation in medicine from Ludwig Maximilian University Munich. He conducted his postdoctoral training in Alan Jasanoff’s laboratory at MIT before starting a laboratory at Helmholtz Center Munich (IBMI/IDG) and joining the medical faculty of Technische Universitaet Muenchen. The Westmeyer laboratory is developing next-generation molecular imaging and control technology to enable closed-loop cell circuit control with spatiotemporal precision and deep-tissue penetration for neuroscientific applications.