Energy harvesting or energy scavenging technology allows capturing unused ambient energy such as vibration, strain, light, temperature gradients and variations, energy of gas and liquid flows, and converting into usable electrical energy. Due to advances in low-power portable microelectronics, the batteries in general provide a finite amount of power. Energy harvesting is a perfect match for these as well as wireless devices which otherwise depend on battery power. Thus, it can provide sustained, cost-effective, and environment friendlier solutions for various low-power applications. In the recent past, to provide sustained power to these micro- and nanodevices, these unconventional methods for waste energy harvesting and scavenging are being explored.1, 2, 3 Efforts have been made to recover electric power from mechanical vibrations,1, 2 light,3 and spatial and temporal temperature variations.3 Waste thermal and mechanical energy of asphalts’ pavement can also be a potential source for low-power electronics; to date, this concept has not been explored in particular via pyroelectricity. However, recently efforts are being made in large scale in Israel by paving kilometers of roads with a specially designed series of piezoelectric modules.4, 5
The amazing pyroelectric materials basically convert most of the electromagnetic radiations spectrum (ultraviolet, infrared, microwave, x-rays, terahertz) energy into electrical energy, mean transforms photons to phonons to electrons.6 Thus, these materials can be exploited to convert thermal energy into electricity. The pyroelectrics are mainly used as uncooled wide-band infrared detectors included in numerous scientific and medical instruments.6 A popular application of the pyroelectric element is in the regular household motion burglar's alarm/sensors. The slight change in temperature from infrared radiations emitted by human bodies in motion, produces electric charges on the surface of the pyroelectric sensor's element, and hence triggers an alarm. In particular, a charge is produced when the material's temperature is altered (increase or decrease) as a function of time by any suitable means. In the recent past, researchers have started exploring the pyroelectrics and piezoelectrics as possible energy harvesters on both theoretical and experimental arenas.1, 2, 3, 7, 8, 9, 10 Most of the innovative research deals with harvesting from vibrations8 and a very few deal with harvesting via pyroelectricity.11, 12, 13, 14, 15 The performance of pyroelectric materials depends strongly on their thermophysical and electrical properties. There are only a few high performance pyroelectrics known so far suitable for infrared detecting and imaging devices, both in single- and polycrystalline and composite forms: triglycine sulfate (TGS) family, lithium tantalate (LT), barium strontium titanate, polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) and its co-polymers, modified lead zirconate tantalate (PZT), poly (vinylidene fluoride-trifluoroethylene) [P(VDF-TrFE)]:PZT, and others.6, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 Energy harvesting is generally based on Ericsson pyroelectric cycles in a relaxor ceramic of lead magnesium niobate-lead titanate [0.9Pb (Mg0.34Nb0.66) O3-0.10(PbTiO3; PMN-PT)].21 Zhu did the simulation for harvested energy based on ferroelectric-paraelectric (FE-PE) transition in Pb(Zn.34Nb.66)0.955Ti0.045O3 single crystal which led to 500 mJ/g for an applied field equal to 50 kV/mm.22 Xie investigated energy harvesting from high temperature increase (45°C to 140°C in ∼10 s: 15°C/s heating rate), i.e., pyroelectric effect using the PZT sample via simple modeling and found that measured and predicted results showed good agreement with peak power density of 0.23 μW/cm2.15 It is worth mentioning that such heating rate (15°C/s) sources are generally not available. Navid worked on purified and porous P(VDF-TrFE) in order to improve the figure-of-merit for energy harvesting (FE = p2/ɛ′). For the commercial, purified, and porous films, FE was 7.93, 10.17, and 5.24 J/m3·K2, respectively.23 The composites, polymer-pyroelectrics, to the best of the authors’ knowledge, have not been investigated for energy harvesting applications. Composites contain two or more chemically different materials or phases. The composites show properties derived from individual components.18, 24 The mechanical strength of polymer (PVDF) and high pyroelectric activity (but low strength) of PZT creates high-strength functional PVDF:PZT composites. Thus, it is possible to tailor electrical, pyroelectric, and other physical properties of these materials as per the requirements of the specific application. Several researchers including the authors of this paper have investigated pyroelectric, piezoelectric, and other physical properties of composites.18, 24 Wen and Chung investigated the pyroelectric behavior of cement-based materials.25 These researchers showed that the steel/carbon-nanofibers increase the dielectric properties of cement composites. Recently, the preliminary investigations by Batra of pyroelectric polymer composites: silver nanoparticles embedded in P(VDF-TrFE):LT, indicate an enhancement in pyroelectric performance as compared with virgin P(VDF-TrFE):LT composites.26
Electric energy harvesting, to the best of our knowledge, by application of pyroelectricity via the temporal temperature fluctuations of pavements (thermal energy of roads), has not been investigated. The proposed concept and features, if realized in practice, could ensure sustained and uninterrupted power supply to wireless microsensors, pavement-management-system hardware, and other civil engineering applications; thereby providing a contribution to energy conservation. Further, electrical and pyroelectric investigations of important pyroelectric materials are warranted with regard to their applications in energy harvesting roads. In the present paper, the electrical and pyroelectric properties of high performance single- and polycrystalline and composite materials including those designed/fabricated by the authors have been investigated. An appropriate model and foregoing parameters were utilized to numerically simulate the voltage and electrical energy generated via the pyroelectric effect, stored in a capacitor over an extended period of time.14 The available pavement's temperature data in Huntsville, Alabama were incorporated as a heat-energy source. The use of single crystals of the TGS family, triglycine selenate (TGSe), for energy harvesting roads was predicted to be better than other candidate materials. Finally, the potential of harvesting electrical energy from pavement's temperature variation via pyroelectric effect is also discussed including via piezoelectricity as pyroelectric materials are also piezoelectric.
Experimental Details and Methodology
A brief description of the characteristics of pyroelectric materials is worth presenting for lucidity.
All crystalline materials are categorized into one of the possible 32 different classes, i.e., point groups divided by using the symmetry elements: i. center of symmetry, ii. axes of rotation, iii. mirror planes, and iv. several combinations of them. The 32 point groups are subdivisions of 7 basic crystal systems that are, in order of ascending symmetry, triclinic, monoclinic, orthorhombic, tetragonal, rhombohedral (trigonal), hexagonal, and cubic. Eleven of these forms are centrosymmetric. Of the remaining 21 noncentrosymmetric groups, 20 are piezoelectrics, meaning that these materials produce an electric surface charge in response to applied mechanical stress. Of the 20 piezoelectric crystal classes, 10 crystals have a permanent electric dipole, and equilibrium of the electrostatic potential caused by this dipole is distorted by mechanical stress (piezoelectricity) or temperature change (pyroelectricity). Certain pyroelectrics can be further divided as ferroelectric materials. The ferroelectric group is a subgroup of the spontaneously polarized pyroelectric crystals. On one hand, the polarization of ferroelectric is similar to the polarization of pyroelectric. On the other hand, there is a difference between the two polarizations because the ferroelectric polarization is reversible by an external applied electric field, provided that the applied field is less than the dielectric breakdown of the materials. Therefore, materials that can be defined as ferroelectrics must have two characteristics: 1. the presence of spontaneous polarization and 2. reversibility of the polarization under an electric field. A ferroelectric material is therefore both pyroelectric and piezoelectric, and these materials are also termed as smart materials.19, 23
The pyroelectric materials and appropriate electrical circuit for ultimately designing a single domain ‘micro-electric harvester’ for the modeling and numerical simulation for their energy harvesting from pavements via pyroelectricity are presented in Table 1 and Fig. 1, respectively. A variety of materials were selected from three categories: i. single crystalline: TGSe, LT; ii. polycrystalline: lead metaniobate (PN), doped lead lanthanum zirconate titanate, lead lanthanum zirconate titanate (PLZT), modified lead metaniobate (PN), lead lanthanum zirconate titanate (8/40/60; PLZT-1), modified lead titanate (MPT); and iii. polymer pyroelectric composites: Portland cement:nanocarbon fibers and silver nanoparticles embedded in P(VDF-TrFE):LT(PVT:LT-Ag).
a. Single crystalline pyroelectric materials: Triglycine selenate [(CH2NH2COOH)3.H2SeO4; TGSe], a well-known pyroelectric material with monoclinic crystal structure is used for room-temperature infrared detectors. Its Curie temperature is in the vicinity of 22°C, thus leading to very high pyroelectric activity around ambient temperatures.19 Lithium tantalate (LiTaO3; LT) with perovskite structure is widely applied in pyroelectric point detectors due to its high pyroelectric coefficient and low relative dielectric constant.20 It has excellent mechanical stability, making it a good candidate for piezoelectric materials as well.
b. Polycrystalline pyroelectric materials: A wide range of polycrystalline materials with perovskite structure is available for pyroelectric device applications, such as PZT, PLZT, multilayered PZT films, and others.20 These ceramics are relatively low in cost to manufacture by using standard mixed-ceramic oxide processing steps, and are both mechanically and chemically robust. These properties seem suitable for use in the proposed application: energy harvesting by embedding in roads.
c. Composite pyroelectric materials: There are also organic ferroelectric as well as pyroelectric materials available, such as, Poly vinylidene fluoride ((CH2-CF2)n; PVDF) and its co-polymer with trifluoroethylene P(VDF-TrFE) (70/30). PVDF and P(VDF-TrFE) copolymer consists of a crystalline and an amorphous fraction. Unlike PVDF, the introduction of a small amount of TrFE causes the copolymer to crystallize directly into the β phase from the melt. The P(VDF-TrFE) copolymer is therefore made to be pyroelectric without stretching, as with PVDF. In the −40°C to +100°C temperature ranges, both show significant pyroelectric and piezoelectric behavior.20 Thus, it is worth investigating polymer composites: silver nanoparticles embedded in P(VDF-TrFE):LT (PVT:LT-Ag) and Portland cement-nanocarbon fiber reinforced (Ce-NFC) composites. Thus, these were fabricated in bulk and thick film forms,26 respectively. To prepare the cement composite specimens, the ordinary Portland cement, poly-vinyl alcohol (PVA), and carbon nanofibers were mixed thoroughly. PVA acts as a binder within the cement. No aggregate was added. The carbon nano-fiber (PR-19-XT-LHT) was obtained from Pyrograph Products, Inc. Cedarville, Ohio. The weighed mixture of cement composite was mixed in water to make a paste of suitable viscosity. The paste was compressed in a steel mound to form disks of diameter 10 mm and thickness 2.0 mm approximately. The disks were then cured at 25°C at 100% humidity for 24 h to speed up the hydration process of the cement matrix. The preparation technologies of the composites and the above cited materials have been recently presented by Batra elsewhere.18, 20
Properties of investigated smart materials; Pyroelectric coefficient (p, nC/cm2K), dielectric constant (ɛ′; real part).
|No.||Material||Acronym||Sample Form||Coefficient (P)||Constant (ɛ′)||References|
|1||Doped Lead Lanthanum Zirconate Titanate||DPLZT||Bulk Ceramic||41||768||20|
|2||Lead Lanthanum Zirconate Titanate||PLZT||Bulk Ceramic||45||700||20|
|4||Triglycine Selenate||TGSe||Bulk Single Crystals||420||420||20|
|5||Lead Lanthanum Zirconate Titanate (8/40/60)||PLZT-1||Bulk Ceramic||120||429||20|
|6||Lithium Tantalate||LT||Bulk Single Crystals||f(T)*||f(T)*||Present work|
|7||PVDF-Lithium Tantalate composite embedded with Silver nano-particles||PVT:LT-Ag||Thick-Films||f(T)||f(T)||Present work|
|8||Modified Lead Metaniobate||PN||Bulk Ceramic||f(T)||f(T)||Present work|
|9||Modified Lead Titanate||MPT||Bulk Ceramic||f(T)||f(T)||Present work|
|10||Cement – nanoCarbon Fiber Composite (0.63% nanoCarbon fibers)||Ce-NFC||Bulk Ceramic||f(T)||f(T)||Present work|
f(T)* - parameter (p; ɛ′) function of temperature.
Pyroelectric Coefficient (p) and Dielectric Constant (ɛ′)
The relevant parameters required for energy harvesting modeling including the dielectric constant (ɛ′) and pyroelectric coefficient (p) of selected materials were calculated or obtained from the literature. A real part (ɛ′) of the dielectric constant were determined as:
The pyroelectric current Ip was measured at various temperatures at a constant heating rate, and the pyroelectric coefficient (p) was calculated using the relationship:
Results and Discussion
Figures 2 and 3 show the dependence of dielectric constant (ɛ′) and pyroelectric coefficient (p) on temperature of selected materials listed in Table 1. All of the materials show the dependence of ɛ′ and p over temperature; ɛ′ and p increase with an increase in temperature as expected in pyroelectrics. Modified lead niobate shows the highest ɛ′ whereas PVT:LT-Ag shows the lowest. The highest pyroelectric coefficient is obtained from PVT:LT-Ag composite. In the case of the cement composites, p also increases with the increase in carbon nanofiber content (Fig. 5). The observed increase in p of cement composite with carbon nanofiber with the increase in temperature is different from that reported by Wen and Chung.25 Figure 4 shows the variation of ɛ′ for the cement composite with different percentages of carbon nanofiber content. The observed increase in dielectric constant in cement composites can be attributed to the increase in mobility of ions as the temperature increases, whereas in the case of other materials, the increase of ɛ′ is due to the increase in dipolar moments in the material. It is evident that ordinary Portland cement behaves similar to typical pyroelectric materials.
Energy Harvesting Capacity of Materials Investigated Through Modeling and Numerical Simulation
The pyroelectric electric generator is modeled as a current source with a capacitor and a resistor in parallel with a current source.20 The current is generated within the cell with the change in temperature. Figure 1 shows the circuit used to model pyroelectric sensors used for energy conversion and charge storage. Equation 2 indicates that the pyroelectric current is directly proportional to the rate of change of temperature. However, one problem with this behavior is that the current will flow in the opposite direction when the rate changes from positive to negative or from negative to positive. In other words, heating followed by cooling or cooling followed by heating will produce charge accumulation in a different direction. However, to charge an external capacitor it is essential that the capacitor be charged continuously. To mitigate the problem, a full bridge diode rectifier circuit, as shown in Fig. 1, can be used. The pyroelectric source is connected to an external capacitor (CE) and an external resistor (RE). There are two pairs of diodes; one pair is used for each direction of charge flow. Diodes (D1–D2) are used when charge is flowing in one direction and diodes (D3–D4) are used when the charges flow in the other direction. At each time only the forward biased diodes work, the other two pairs block the current flow under reverse biased condition. As it can be seen, in both cases the external capacitor (CE) is charged via charge flows in one direction and that causes the voltage to increase across the external storage capacitor.
The charge flow in the two-capacitor system can be modeled as follows: When the new charge is accumulated, it is distributed in both capacitors and the charge balance equation can be written as:14
When storing energy from temperature change/fluctuations, the values of CP and CE should be optimized for the highest energy storage. Furthermore, the external resistor, RE, and the external capacitor, CE, can be adjusted to obtain fast charging. The parameters of the materials presented in Table 1 have been used for the simulation. The simulated voltage and energy stored are shown in Figs. 7, 8 for the materials shown in Table 1, respectively. The circuit is simulated assuming 1 cm2 area of the pyroelectric cell with 0.1-cm thickness. The external storage capacitor is assumed to be 1.0 μF. For the materials for which the pyroelectric coefficient and the dielectric constant are functions of temperature, the actual functional relationship has been used; for other materials, constant values of p and ɛ′ have been used. The capacitance of the pyroelectric element was determined using Eq. 1. Figure 7 shows the accumulated voltage for 800 h during the month of May starting from zero voltage. Figure 8 shows the associated accumulated energy (in Joules). The highest maximum voltage accumulated during the month of May is approximately 278 V from TGSe and the corresponding electric energy is approximately 0.04 J. It is worth mentioning that this maximum voltage can be controlled by choosing a suitable value for external storage capacitor, CE; however, for the present modeling and numerical simulation of value of the electric energy in Huntsville, Alabama, the capacitance of 1.0 μF is utilized.
In this study, important pyroelectrics in single- and polycrystalline and nanocomposite forms have been fabricated and/or obtained. The dielectric and pyroelectric properties of some of the materials fabricated have been determined. The materials’ parameters of interest have been used to perform numerical simulation with actual pavement temperature data obtained from the climatic database of MEPDG.27 The numerical simulation performed indicates that the methodology and model adopted are sound. Among the pyroelectrics selected for simulation, TGSe is an attractive candidate for energy harvesting from pavements due to its higher pyroelectric coefficient near ambient temperatures. Pyroelectric current (energy) is typically a function of dT (change in temperature) at a given temperature; for larger temperature (T), the energy generated will be high; higher values of both p and dT will give higher energy generated.
Its real application will determine if the predicted performance can be realized or not. To fabricate and embed an EH module based on TGSe materials, a technology has to be developed.
It is worth mentioning that electric energy generated due to pyroelectricity in the pavement is location, traffic, time, and population specific due to temperature variation of the pavement in consideration. Since ambient temperature variations, and hence pyroelectric current, in pavement depend on location; for optimum performance, the suitable pyroelectric material-based energy harvesters including the electric circuit have to be selected and designed accordingly. However, only the field applications of pyroelectric materials investigated will determine the suitability of the material based on life, weathering, cost-analysis, and ease of embedding in pavements.
It will be also interesting and important to investigate electric energy generated via both pyroelectric and piezoelectric properties of the same selected material. The hybrid and multimodule energy harvesters can then be designed and fabricated by connecting these elements in a suitable electric circuit. Thus, enhancement of charge-storage rate in the capacitor will be possible.
Further work is in progress to investigate their performance, suitability, and economics by embedding single-element energy harvesters in pavements under laboratory simulated conditions.
The partial financial support for this work through NSF grant (0927644) is acknowledged. The technical assistance provided by members of the Materials Science group, Department of Physics, in particular, Dr. Padmaja Guggilla, is greatly appreciated. Thanks to Mr. Garland Sharp for the fabrication of fixtures used in sample preparation and measurements. Interest and technical assistance of civil engineering undergraduate students (Jacob Cain and Sima Mesert) are greatly appreciated. The authors would like to acknowledge the critical and valuable comments of reviewers.
S. Priya and D. J. Inman, Eds., Energy Harvesting Technologies, Springer, New York (2009). Google Scholar
S. Roundy, P. K. White, and J. Rabaey, Energy Scavenging for Wireless Sensor Networks with Special Focus on Vibration, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, Massachusetts (2004). Google Scholar
S. Beeby and N. White, Energy Harvesting for Autonomous Systems, Artech House, Norwood, Massachusetts (2010). Google Scholar
A. K. Batra, M. D. Aggarwal, P. Guggilla, M. E. Edwards, P. G. Penn, and J. R. Currie Jr., “Pyroelectric materials for uncooled infrared detectors: processing, properties and applications,” NASA Tech. Memo. NASA/TM-2010-6373, 1–71 (2010). Google Scholar
M. T. Penella and M. Gasulla, “A review of commercial energy harvesters for autonomous sensors,” in Proceedings of the Inst. Meas. Tech. Conference – IMTC 2007 (2007). Google Scholar
S. P. Beeby, M. J. Tudor, and N. M. White, “Energy harvesting vibration sources for microsystems applications,” Meas. Sci. Technol. 17, R175–R195 (2006).http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0957-0233/17/12/R01 Google Scholar
H.-U. Kim, W.-H. Lee, H. V. Rasika Dias, and S. Priya, “Piezoelectric microgenerator-current status and challenges,” IEEE Trans. Ultrason. Ferroelectr. Freq. Control 56(8), 1555–1568 (2009).http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/TUFFC.2009.1220 Google Scholar
G. Sebald, E. Lefeuvre, and D. Guyomar, “Pyroelectric energy conversion: Optimization principles,” IEEE Trans. Ultrason. Ferroelectr. Freq. Control 55, 538–551 (2008).http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/TUFFC.2008.680 Google Scholar
S. Bauer, “Piezo-, pyro- and ferro-electrets: Soft transducer materials for electromechanical energy conversion,” IEEE Trans. Dielectr. Electr. Insul. 13(5), 953–962 (2006). Google Scholar
R. C. Buchanan and J. Huang, “Pyroelectric and sensor properties of ferroelectric thin films for energy conversion,” J. Eur. Ceram. Soc. 19, 1467–1471 (1999).http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0955-2219(98)00454-3 Google Scholar
J. Xie, X. P. Mane, C. W. Green, K. M. Mossi, and K. Leang, “Performance of piezoelectric materials for pyroelectric energy harvesting,” J. Intell. Mat. Syst. Struct. 21, 243–249 (2009).http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/1045389X09352818 Google Scholar
A. K. Batra, M. D. Aggarwal, and R. B. Lal, “Growth and characteristics of TGS crystals grown in microgravity environment of space and on earth: An update,” in Crystal Growth of Technologically Important Materials, Allied Publishers Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi, India (2003). Google Scholar
A. K. Batra, J. R. Currie, S. K. Aggarwal, M. D. Aggarwal, and R. B. Lal, “Present status of TGS-based pyroelectric infrared detectors and computational simulation of their integration with silicon technology,” Proc. SPIE 5209, 133–147 (2004).http://dx.doi.org/10.1117/12.504365 Google Scholar
A. K. Batra, M. D. Aggarwal, M. Edwards, and A. S. Bhalla, “Present status of polymer: Ceramic composites for pyroelectric infrared detectors,” Ferroelectrics 366, 84–121 (2008).http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00150190802363207 Google Scholar
M. D. Aggarwal, A. K. Batra, R. B. Lal, B. G. Penn, and D. Frazier, “Growth and characteristics of bulk crystal grown from solution on earth and microgravity,” in Handbook of Crystal Growth, Springer, New York (2010). Google Scholar
A. K. Batra, M. D. Aggarwal, P. Guggilla, M. E. Edwards, P. G. Penn, and J. R. Currie Jr., “Pyroelectric materials for uncooled infrared detectors: Processing, properties and applications,” NASA Tech. Memo NASA/TM-2010-6373, 1–71 (2010). Google Scholar
A. Khodayari, S. Pruvost, G. Sebald, D. Guyomar, and S. Mohammadi, “Nonlinear pyroelectric energy harvesting from relaxor single crystals,” IEEE Trans. Ultrason. Ferroelectr. Freq. Control 56, 693–699 (2009).http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/TUFFC.2009.1092 Google Scholar
H. Zhu, S. Pruvost, D. Guyomar, and A. Khodayari, “Thermal energy harvesting from Pb(Zn1/3Nb2/3)0.955Ti0.045O3 single crystals phase transitions,” J. Appl. Phys. 106, 124102 (2009).http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.3271144 Google Scholar
A. Navid, C. S. Lynch, and L. Pilon, “Purified and porous poly(vinylidene fluoride-trifluoroethylene) thin films for pyroelectric infrared sensing and energy harvesting,” Smart. Mater. Struct. 19, 055006 (2010).http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0964-1726/19/5/055006 Google Scholar
P. Guggilla, A. K. Batra, and M. E. Edwards, “Electrical characterization of LiTaO3:P(VDF-TrFE) Composites,” J. Mater. Sci. 44, 5469–5479 (2009).http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10853-009-3753-8 Google Scholar
A. K. Batra, J. Corda, P. Guggilla, M. D. Aggarwal, and M. E. Edwards, “Electrical properties of silver nanoparticles reinforced LiTaO3:P(VDF-TrFE) composite films,” Proc. SPIE 7419, 741904 (2009).http://dx.doi.org/10.1117/12.824384 Google Scholar
Guide for Mechanistic Empirical Design of New and Rehabilitated Pavement Structures: Final Report, National Cooperative Highway Research Program (NCHRP) (2004). NCHRP Project No. 1-37A, Transportation Research Board, National Research Council, Washington DC. Google Scholar