The unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) is an emerging technology applied recently in land cover classification, owing to its ability to acquire very high-resolution spatial data, that has provided an effective means for detailed land cover mapping, especially for a small island area. Selecting suitable UAV-acquired data and exploring the combined use of UAV multitype data are of significance for island mapping. Nine classification models were established through a fusion method of visible, multispectral, and light detection and ranging (LIDAR) data acquired by UAVs. A two-level hierarchical land cover classification (level 1 and level 2) of the Donkey Island in China was performed using geographic object-based image analysis with random forest classifier. We investigated the performance of land cover classification models containing different sets of features (spectral, height, intensity, and shape features extracted from UAV data) and evaluated the importance of various features. The results demonstrate that the overall accuracy (OA) of the models generally increase with decreasing detail and the amount of information entering the classification process. The OA achieved range from 82.08% to 92.54% and 74.12% to 85.08% across the nine models for level 1 and level 2, respectively. The best result was achieved with a model combining all features based on multispectral and LIDAR data. Height and intensity information input significantly affect the quality of classification models positively, with height apparently more significant than LIDAR information. When comparing different features, spectral features prominently assist in discriminating land cover classes. The importance of height and intensity features to classification accuracy varies for the classification models, showing greater importance in models based on visible data.